Look beyond the strongest portfolio image
A transparent bottle, reflective surface or subtle color variant can expose problems that a generic lifestyle scene will not. Ask for a neutral view, a contextual scene and a relevant variant if those match the catalog. A visually impressive sample should still be checked against the actual product.
Clarify whether the supplier delivers new scenes or mainly crops of one scene. Ask how the team returns to approved references when packaging changes. Apply the same acceptance criteria to later deliveries, not just the sample. Catalog photography and advertising images have different purposes, so the selection should reflect what the customer needs to understand in each use.
Split a large catalog by job: a batch tool or a photographer for packshots on white, and a managed service for hero and campaign scenes. Hundreds of SKUs on white need a repeatable process: a batch tool your team runs, or a photographer. Hero and campaign scenes are needed only for the products you advertise.
Run the same difficult SKU through each route you are considering and count your team's review hours.
How AI Vidia answers these checks
On client work, a creative director checks every file against photos of your real product before you see it, and one revision round is included. Ad images are delivered in 9:16 as standard; product-page and collection stills can be agreed per client on request. All our rights in the finished ads transfer to you on delivery; AI presenters are licensed as they appear in your ads.
The published plans make every monthly concept as 4 videos and 4 image ads, and 4 image ads swap for 1 video in any month; for stills we agree the number of images per catalog in writing before production starts.
If you only need catalog packshots on white, a product photographer is the better buy. You send the product photos you already have and sign off a written product fact sheet before anything is generated; how we check product accuracy covers the rest.
We publish a worked example of a product-accuracy check on HAVREL, a fictional face serum: there was no real product to photograph, so its four reference images were generated, and every verdict came from an AI review pass. The demo proves no client result.