Compare production responsibilities before vendor names. A tool may generate a scene, a producer turns a brief into an ad, and whoever runs the ads, the brand's team or the production partner, launches and evaluates it. These jobs can sit with different people.
If you already have a media buyer and production is the bottleneck, add production capacity: a studio owns agreed deliverables while your team keeps approval. Your photos and existing footage often cover the product; a new shoot is needed mainly for texture or handling.
Three ways to organise production
In-house production suits teams with scripting, art direction and editing capacity. Assess whether a tool removes a specific bottleneck, counting training, selection and correction time.
An external specialist may suit product animation or a bounded series of backgrounds. A recurring partnership may suit ongoing output and coordination. Ask what remains your responsibility. A subscription does not automatically supply a complete production function.
Before choosing, decide what the ads need from your existing material. Product photos usually show appearance: pack, label, colour and shape. Real footage is often needed where texture, handling or a real person's own experience is the point, and existing footage can be cut in alongside AI scenes. AI is strongest at the supporting context around them, such as settings, routines and transitions. For a pet-food pack, photos cover the box and pouch; if the food's texture in the bowl is the point, film a serving or send footage you already have. The guides to products that are hard for AI video and to AI presenters and real creators show which scenes need which source, and the guide to AI labels on ads covers labelling.
Choose for the missing capability
If you already have a media buyer and production is the slow part, name what is missing before comparing suppliers.
- Speed or tooling only: your team can direct, script and edit, but needs faster generation. Software and training may be enough.
- Selected execution tasks: your team owns the ads, but a specific job, such as product animation or a background series, is beyond its skills. A specialist for that task fits.
- The production function itself: nobody has time to turn briefs into checked, named files every week. A managed studio that is responsible for agreed deliverables fits, while your team keeps approval and the media buyer keeps the campaign.
The guide to in-house AI creative versus an agency goes deeper into the first option.
